Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Bisone's avatar

I admired the movie, for all the reasons you mention and more. I also liked this article, and agree with most of what you say. My one caveat has to do with this:

"I realized that there is no “John Milton”, of course. There is no “Satan”, in the corporeal sense. This is a narrative device. The truth is that Evil lies in the heart of man."

You go on to write that Satan isn't real in the "corporeal" sense. I might somewhat agree with this, depending on your defintion of corporeal (and perhaps of "real", too). The problem is that the domain in which men make their judgments and choices is neither mapped nor mappable by scientific procedure, or even by reason more generally. The domain of consciousness and its transactions is essentially non-local. We can measure the effects, but not the causes.

So when we impose artificial limits on it, such as claiming that consciousness is inseparable from its particular material expression and structure, I think we risk falling into a very old trap. We are drawing a line we aren't qualified to draw, and at the same time rejecting nearly every human ancestral story and artistic insight in the process. If we take a step back, the notion that a mind -- including a malevolent, non-human mind -- cannot observe or think or feel without a specific and coherent body is an inversion of Christ's good news.

In other words, if we accept the concept of the intelligent, immortal, free-willed soul as real, and as a creature that endures after physical death, the notion that there cannot be other creatures without observable bodies stops making sense. Our reasons for thinking so may be mostly pure, as I believe Descartes' were mostly pure when he developed his theory of automata. But there is still a kind of hubris in it, and the fall could be very steep. Evil is a snake that dwells in the human heart, yes, meaning the bodies our conscious souls "possess" during life. But there are other snakes out there in the wild, which would very much like to evict us and take up residence.

Expand full comment
Michelle Lobdell's avatar

You encapsulated the material and spiritual reality of the embrace of objective morality perfectly in a way that will resonate with many. Thank you for that.

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts